American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The american lawn mower company 16 inch manual reel mower alternatives list helps you find similar tools if the original does not fit your needs. This 16-inch, 5-blade manual mower is lightweight at 20 pounds and offers a pollution-free cut. It features an adjustable height from 0.5 to 2.5 inches and durable heat-treated alloy steel blades. However, you might prefer a different cutting width, a bagging option, or an electric power source for larger areas. You may also want a brand with a padded handle or a wider deck for efficiency.
We selected these 6 alternatives because their specifications overlap with the original product. The list includes other manual reel mowers with varying blade counts, such as the Scotts 7-blade model, and wider options like the LawnMaster 20-inch mower. We also included electric and dethatching tools if you need different functions. Each pick is ranked by how well it matches your potential requirements for size, power, and application. You can compare the specs to decide which tool best suits your lawn care routine.
Our top pick: American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower.
How each alternative compares
American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual
This model keeps the same 16-inch cutting width and manual power source as the original. It weighs slightly less at 18 pounds, making it easier to push. The key difference is the integrated grass catcher. You can collect clippings instead of leaving them on the lawn. The handle extends to 48.8 inches, which is taller than the original’s 45 inches. This adds height for better ergonomics. Choose this if you want to bag waste without switching to gas or electric power. It suits small, level lawns where maintaining a tidy appearance is a priority.
Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower
Scotts offers a 16-inch cut with a 7-blade reel instead of the original’s 5 blades. This extra blade count aims for a finer cut on fine grass types. The mower weighs 23 pounds, which is 3 pounds heavier than the original. It features a padded handle for comfort during longer pushes. The height reaches 49.5 inches, providing a more upright posture. You give up the vintage aesthetic and wooden handle for a modern black design. Pick this if you value exercise and precision on small lawns with delicate grass varieties.
LawnMaster 20-Inch Manual Push Reel Mower
LawnMaster widens the cutting path to 20 inches, covering more ground per pass. It retains the manual power source, so you must push it. The unit is compact, measuring 27.1 inches in length. It lacks a specified weight in the data, but the wider deck suggests a different build. You trade the 16-inch precision for broader coverage. This suits users who want to reduce mowing time on larger areas without using batteries. It is a practical choice for those willing to exert more effort for a wider, eco-friendly trim.
BILT HARD 16-Inch Corded Electric Dethatcher
BILT HARD shifts from cutting to dethatching. It uses 15-amp electric power, requiring an outlet. The width remains 16 inches, but the weight jumps to 57.3 pounds. This is a heavy-duty tool for soil health, not grass length. You give up the lightweight, manual nature of the original for mechanical scarifying. The handle reaches 42.5 inches. Choose this if your lawn needs aeration and dethatching more than simple cutting. It is a specialized tool for homeowners prioritizing soil maintenance over routine mowing.
LawnMaster 16-Inch 12Amp Electric Mower
LawnMaster provides electric power with a 12-amp corded motor. The cutting width stays at 16 inches. It weighs 30.2 pounds, which is heavier than the original. You gain consistent power without pushing as hard, but you are tethered to an outlet. The height is 13 inches, and the length is 30.4 inches. This model fits small yards with easy access to power. Pick this if you want reliable corded performance in a lightweight package. It is a practical upgrade for those who find manual pushing too strenuous.
Great States 16-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower
Great States offers another 16-inch, 5-blade manual option. It weighs 20.9 pounds, nearly identical to the original. The design is white and modern, lacking the vintage wood handle. The height is 13.8 inches, and the length is 23.1 inches. It is a solid choice for small yards where quiet operation matters. You get a similar cut and maintenance level. Choose this if you prefer a different aesthetic or want a comparable manual mower. It suits users who do not mind pushing for a clean, even cut without the classic vintage look.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower
Best for: Small, flat lawns and quiet operation
- Power Source
- manual
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Deck Material
- heat-treated alloy steel
- Cutting Height
- 0.5 in-2.5 in
- Application
- Lawn
- Dimensions
- 45 × 22 × 20 inches
View on Amazon: American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower Affiliate link
This manual reel mower offers a 16-inch cutting width with five heat-treated alloy steel blades. It features an adjustable cutting height ranging from 0.5 to 2.5 inches. The unit weighs 20 pounds and includes durable 10-inch polymer wheels with metal hub caps. Its lightweight, pollution-free design makes it suitable for small, flat lawns where quiet operation and low maintenance are priorities.
Pros
- 16-inch cutting width with five blades
- Adjustable cutting height from 0.5 to 2.5 inches
- Lightweight 20-pound build for easy maneuverability
- Heat-treated alloy steel blades stay sharp
- Pollution-free and noise-free operation
Cons
- Manual power requires physical effort
- No grass catcher included
- Limited to small, flat lawns
Good fit if
- You have a small, flat lawn under 1,000 square feet
- You prefer quiet, zero-emission yard work
- You want a lightweight mower for easy storage
Skip if
- You need to cut thick or wet grass
- You have a large or hilly property
- You want electric or gas power
Verdict: American Lawn Mower 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower is a practical, lightweight option for small, flat lawns where quiet operation is valued over power.
American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual
Best for: Bagging clippings on small, level lawns
- Power Source
- Manual reel
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Cutting Height
- 1/2 to 2-1/2 in
- Mowing Function
- Grass catcher
- Application
- Lawn
View on Amazon: American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual Affiliate link
This manual reel mower features a 16-inch five-blade cutting width and includes a grass catcher for bagging clippings. It offers a cutting range from 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches via manual wheel and roller adjustments. Weighing 18 pounds, it operates without gas or electricity. This model suits users with level, regularly maintained lawns who prefer quiet, engine-free operation.
Pros
- Includes a grass catcher for clipping collection
- 16-inch five-blade reel provides a scissor-like cut
- Adjustable cutting height from 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches
- Weighs 18 pounds for manageable portability
Cons
- Height adjustment requires manual repositioning of components
- Grass catcher may be less practical for large lawns
- Struggles with tall grass, weeds, or uneven terrain
Good fit if
- You want to collect grass clippings without a powered mower
- You have a small, level lawn that is mowed frequently
- You prefer quiet, manual operation without cords or batteries
Skip if
- You need to mow tall grass, weeds, or uneven ground
- You require quick height changes during a mowing session
- You have a large lawn with heavy clipping volume
Verdict: American Lawn Mower 1604-16 with Grass Catcher fits small, level lawns where you want to bag clippings without using gas or electricity. It is a practical tool for maintaining regularly cut grass.
Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower
Best for: Small lawns with fine grass types
- Power Source
- Manual reel
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Application
- Lawn
- Dimensions
- 19.3 × 21.8 × 49.5 inches
- Weight
- 23 pounds
View on Amazon: Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower Affiliate link
The Scotts 2607-16S is a manual reel mower with a 16-inch cutting width and a 7-blade reel. It weighs 23 pounds and features a padded U-handle for comfort. This model is designed for fine to medium turf grasses like Bermuda and fescue. It suits small to medium lawns where you want a clean cut without electricity or gas.
Pros
- 16-inch cutting width for efficient coverage
- 7-blade reel for precise cutting on fine grasses
- Padded U-handle for improved control and comfort
- Lightweight 23-pound build for easy maneuverability
Cons
- No grass catcher included for clippings
- Push-only drive requires physical effort
- Manual operation lacks electric or battery power
Good fit if
- You have a small to medium lawn
- You prefer manual exercise over motorized tools
- You maintain fine turf like Bermuda or fescue
Skip if
- You need to collect grass clippings
- You have large or thick overgrown areas
- You want to avoid physical pushing effort
Verdict: Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower is a lightweight, manual option for small lawns with fine grass. It offers a precise cut through its 7-blade reel and padded handle, making it ideal for users who value simplicity and exercise.
LawnMaster 20-Inch Manual Push Reel Mower
Best for: wider manual cutting without batteries
- Power Source
- manual reel
- Cutting Width
- 20 in
- Drive Type
- push
- Cutting Height
- 1.3-2.6 in, 9 positions
- Application
- Lawn
- Dimensions
- 27.1 × 18.2 × 10.6 inches
View on Amazon: LawnMaster 20-Inch Manual Push Reel Mower Affiliate link
This LawnMaster mower offers a 20-inch cutting width, which is wider than the 16-inch models in this guide. It uses a five-blade reel design for a scissor-like cut. You can adjust the height across nine positions, ranging from 1.3 to 2.6 inches. The unit relies on manual push power with 10-inch front wheels for maneuverability. It requires no gas or batteries, making it an environmentally friendly option for small to medium lawns.
Pros
- 20-inch cutting width for faster coverage
- Nine adjustable cutting height positions
- Five-blade steel reel for clean cuts
- No gas or batteries required
Cons
- Requires manual pushing effort
- No grass catcher included
- Lacks electric or battery power assist
Good fit if
- You want a wider cut than 16 inches
- You prefer a battery-free operation
- You have a small to medium lawn
Skip if
- You need electric power for steep hills
- You require a grass catcher for debris
- You prefer a narrower 16-inch deck
Verdict: LawnMaster 20-Inch 5-Blade Manual Reel Mower fits users who want a wider cut without batteries. It suits those willing to push the mower for a clean, eco-friendly trim.
BILT HARD 16-Inch Corded Electric Dethatcher
Best for: dethatching and scarifying lawns
- Power Source
- 15 Amp corded
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Cutting Height
- 5 positions
- Mowing Function
- 2-in-1
- Application
- Lawn
- Dimensions
- 40 × 20 × 42.5 inches
View on Amazon: BILT HARD 16-Inch Corded Electric Dethatcher Affiliate link
This BILT HARD unit is a 16-inch electric dethatcher and scarifier. It uses a 15 Amp motor to drive a 16-inch raking path. You get a 2-in-1 design with separate rollers for dethatching and scarifying. The tool-free depth adjustment offers five settings. A 14.5-gallon grass bag collects debris. It suits homeowners needing to remove thatch and aerate soil for healthier grass.
Pros
- 15 Amp copper motor for robust power
- 2-in-1 design switches between dethatching and scarifying
- 16-inch raking path covers ground efficiently
- 14.5-gallon removable grass bag for debris collection
- Five-position depth adjustment for precise control
Cons
- Corded power limits mobility and range
- 57.3-pound weight makes it heavy to maneuver
- Not a lawn mower; requires prior mowing
Good fit if
- You need to remove thick thatch layers
- You want to aerate soil for better nutrient absorption
- You have a reliable outdoor power outlet nearby
Skip if
- You are looking for a standard lawn mower
- You need battery-powered cordless operation
- You want to mow tall or wet grass
Verdict: BILT HARD 16-Inch 15Amp Dethatcher is a heavy-duty tool for homeowners who need to aerate and dethatch their lawns. It fits those prioritizing soil health over simple cutting.
LawnMaster 16-Inch 12Amp Electric Mower
Best for: small yards with easy outlet access
- Power Source
- 12 Amp corded electric
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Cutting Height
- 1.4-3 in, 5 positions
- Application
- Lawn
- Dimensions
- 30.4 × 18.2 × 13 inches
- Weight
- 30.2 pounds
View on Amazon: LawnMaster 16-Inch 12Amp Electric Mower Affiliate link
The LawnMaster MEB1216K is a 16-inch electric mower designed for small yards. It features a 12-amp motor running at 3,500 RPM and weighs just 30.2 pounds. You get five cutting heights from 1.4 to 3 inches and an 8-gallon grass catcher. The handle folds for compact storage. This model suits users who want corded power without the hassle of gas or battery charging.
Pros
- 12-amp motor delivers 3,500 RPM
- 8-gallon grass collection bag included
- Five cutting positions from 1.4 to 3 inches
- Lightweight at 30.2 pounds with folding handle
Cons
- Requires a nearby electrical outlet
- 16-inch cutting width is narrow for large lawns
- No battery option for cordless flexibility
Good fit if
- You have a small yard under 1,000 square feet
- You prefer the consistent power of a corded motor
- You need lightweight equipment for easy maneuvering
Skip if
- You want to mow large areas without extension cords
- You prefer the quiet operation of a reel mower
- You need a wider cutting deck for efficiency
Verdict: LawnMaster 16-Inch 12AMP Electric Mower fits small yards where outlet access is convenient. You get reliable corded power in a lightweight package.
Great States 16-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower
Best for: small lawns seeking quiet, manual mowing
- Power Source
- Manual
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Deck Material
- Alloy steel
- Cutting Height
- 1-2.5 in, adjustable
- Application
- Lawn
View on Amazon: Great States 16-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower Affiliate link
The Great States 415-16 is a 16-inch manual reel mower designed for quiet, gas-free lawn care. It features a 5-blade ball bearing reel and heat-treated alloy steel blades that stay sharp longer. The cutting height adjusts from 1 to 2.5 inches. Weighing 20.9 pounds, it offers easy maneuverability with 10-inch composite wheels and a cushioned T-style handle for comfortable pushing.
Pros
- 16-inch cutting width with a 5-blade ball bearing reel
- Heat-treated alloy steel blades for longer sharpness
- Adjustable cutting height from 1 to 2.5 inches
- Lightweight 20.9-pound design with 10-inch composite wheels
- Cushioned T-style handle for comfortable pushing
Cons
- Manual push operation requires physical effort
- No grass catcher included in the base model
- Smaller 16-inch cutting width limits efficiency on large lawns
Good fit if
- You want a quiet, zero-emission mowing experience
- You have a small to medium-sized lawn under 5,000 square feet
- You prefer simple, tool-less assembly and maintenance
Skip if
- You need to mow large properties quickly
- You prefer electric or gas-powered convenience
- You require a grass catcher for clippings
Verdict: Great States 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower is a solid choice for small yards where quiet operation and low maintenance matter most. It suits users who do not mind pushing a manual mower for a clean, even cut.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower | American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual | Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower | LawnMaster 20-Inch Manual Push Reel Mower | BILT HARD 16-Inch Corded Electric Dethatcher | LawnMaster 16-Inch 12Amp Electric Mower | Great States 16-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Power Source | manual | Manual reel | Manual reel | manual reel | 15 Amp corded | 12 Amp corded electric | Manual |
| Cutting Width | 16 in | 16 in | 16 in | 20 in | 16 in | 16 in | 16 in |
| Drive Type | not stated | Push | Push | push | not stated | not stated | Push |
| Deck Material | heat-treated alloy steel | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Alloy steel |
| Cutting Height | 0.5 in-2.5 in | 1/2 to 2-1/2 in | not stated | 1.3-2.6 in, 9 positions | 5 positions | 1.4-3 in, 5 positions | 1-2.5 in, adjustable |
| Mowing Function | not stated | Grass catcher | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Application | Lawn | Lawn | Lawn | Lawn | Lawn | Lawn | Lawn |
| Dimensions | 45 × 22 × 20 inches | 21.5 × 22 × 48.8 inches | 19.3 × 21.8 × 49.5 inches | 27.1 × 18.2 × 10.6 inches | 40 × 20 × 42.5 inches | 30.4 × 18.2 × 13 inches | 23.1 × 10.6 × 13.8 inches |
| Weight | 20 pounds | 18 pounds | 23 pounds | not stated | 57.3 pounds | 30.2 pounds | 20.9 pounds |
| Size | 16-Inch, 5-Blade | 16" 5 Blade, Grass Catcher | 16-Inch, 7-Blade | 20-Inch | 16 Inch, 15 Amp | 16-Inch | 16-Inch, 5-Blade |
| Color | blue | Red | Black | Orange | Blue | 16-Inch-Black & Orange | White |
| Model | 1895ALM | 1604-16 | 2607-16S | LMRM2001 | TIA-1002 | MEB1216K | 415-16 |
Frequently asked questions
Which manual reel mower is best for small, flat lawns?
The American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower is the top pick for small, flat lawns where quiet operation matters. It weighs 20 pounds and features a 5-blade reel with a 16-inch cutting width. Its compact dimensions make it easy to maneuver in tight spaces without generating noise or emissions.
Can I bag grass clippings with a manual mower?
Yes, the American Lawn Mower 1604-16 includes an integrated grass catcher. This 16-inch, 5-blade manual model weighs 18 pounds and is designed for bagging clippings on small, level lawns. It allows you to maintain a clean yard without using gas or electricity, keeping the process simple and eco-friendly.
What is the widest cutting width for a manual reel mower?
The LawnMaster 20-Inch Manual Push Reel Mower offers the widest cut at 20 inches. It is a 5-blade model that requires no batteries or cords. This wider swath helps you cover more ground quickly while maintaining an eco-friendly, manual mowing experience for users willing to push the unit.
Is there a manual mower with more than five blades?
The Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower features seven blades for a precise cut. It weighs 23 pounds and includes a padded handle for comfort. This manual option is ideal for small lawns with fine grass types, offering simplicity and exercise while delivering a clean trim without external power sources.
Which alternative is best for dethatching and scarifying?
The BILT HARD 16-Inch Corded Electric Dethatcher is designed for dethatching and scarifying. It weighs 57.3 pounds and features a 15-amp motor. This heavy-duty tool prioritizes soil health over simple cutting, making it suitable for homeowners who need to aerate their lawns regularly for better growth and appearance.
What is a good electric alternative to a manual mower?
The LawnMaster 16-Inch 12Amp Electric Mower provides reliable corded power for small yards. It weighs 30.2 pounds and features a 16-inch cutting deck. This model fits users who have easy access to an outlet and want the convenience of electric power without the weight and noise of gas engines.
Which manual mower is the lightest weight option?
The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 is the lightest manual option at 18 pounds. It features a 16-inch cutting width and a 5-blade reel. Its low weight makes it easy to push and maneuver, especially when equipped with the grass catcher, making it practical for maintaining regularly cut grass.