American Lawn Mower Company vs Scotts: Lawn Mowers Compared by Specs
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When you compare the american lawn mower company vs scotts lawn mower options, you see two manual reel mowers that rely on human power. Both models cut grass without gas or electricity. The main difference lies in the cutting width and height adjustment. The American Lawn Mower Company offers a 16-inch cut with a catcher, while the Scotts model provides a wider 20-inch cut. You need to decide if you prefer a smaller deck with collection or a wider deck without a bag.
Key differences
| Aspect | American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual | Scotts 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower |
|---|---|---|
| Cutting Width | 16 inches | 20 inches |
| Power Source | Manual | Manual |
| Cutting Height Range | 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches | 1 to 3 inches |
| Mowing Function | Bagging | Not listed |
| Weight | 18 pounds | 26.9 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual if
- You want a lighter mower that is easier to push on small, flat lawns
- You need to collect grass clippings for a cleaner look
- You prefer a narrower deck for maneuvering around tight garden edges
Choose Scotts 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower if
- You want to cover more ground with each pass due to the wider 20-inch deck
- You need a higher maximum cutting height for taller grass
- You prefer a mower with a cushioned ergonomic handle for comfort
Verdict: Choose the American Lawn Mower Company model if you prioritize a lightweight design and grass collection for smaller, maintained lawns. The Scotts mower is better for you if you want a wider cutting path and a higher maximum cut height for slightly larger areas. Both are manual options that require physical effort.
Specs: Cutting Width and Height
Cutting width
The Scotts model offers a 20-inch cutting width, while the American Lawn Mower Company option provides a 16-inch cut. A wider deck means you cover more ground with each pass. This makes the Scotts mower more efficient for larger, open lawns where you want to minimize overlapping strokes. The narrower American Lawn Mower deck is better suited for smaller yards or tighter spaces between garden beds and obstacles. You should choose the wider option if speed is your priority, or the narrower one if maneuverability in confined areas matters more to your routine.
Height adjustment
Height settings differ significantly between the two. The Scotts mower features a quick-snap adjustment system ranging from 1 to 3 inches. This allows for rapid changes without moving multiple components. The American Lawn Mower Company mower offers a broader range from 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches. However, adjusting it requires manual repositioning of wheels and rollers based on a specific chart. If you prefer fast, tool-less changes, the Scotts system is superior. If you need precise, lower cuts for a manicured look, the American model provides a wider selection of heights.
Weight and portability
Weight affects how easily you can push and store the mower. The American Lawn Mower Company unit weighs 18 pounds, making it the lighter option. This reduces fatigue during long mowing sessions and makes it easier to lift into a garage or shed. The Scotts mower weighs 26.9 pounds. While heavier, this mass may provide better stability on uneven terrain. For most users, the lighter American model is easier to handle, especially if you have physical limitations or need to move the mower frequently for storage.
Grass collection
Only one of these mowers includes a grass catcher. The American Lawn Mower Company model comes with an included catcher that collects a portion of clippings. You must attach a support strap and empty it frequently. The Scotts mower does not list a grass catcher in its specifications or features. If you prefer to collect clippings for a cleaner lawn appearance, the American model is the only viable choice here. If you are comfortable mulching or raking, the lack of a catcher on the Scotts unit is less of an issue.
Blade construction
Both mowers use five-blade reel designs, but the material quality differs. The Scotts mower specifies blades made of heat-treated alloy steel, which helps them stay sharp longer. This suggests better durability and consistent cutting performance over time. The American Lawn Mower Company description highlights the scissor-like cut action but does not specify the blade material or heat treatment. If long-term sharpness and resistance to dulling are important to you, the Scotts construction offers a clear advantage based on the available data.
Which manual reel mower fits your lawn
Users with larger, level lawns
The 20-inch cutting width covers more ground per pass than the 16-inch option. This efficiency reduces total mowing time. The quick-snap height adjustment allows you to change settings from 1 to 3 inches easily. The heat-treated steel blades stay sharp longer, ensuring a clean cut on maintained grass without frequent maintenance.
Those needing precise height control
This model offers a wider cutting range from 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches. While adjustment requires manual repositioning, it provides finer control for specific grass types. The included grass catcher helps manage clippings on smaller, well-kept lawns. Its lighter 18-pound weight makes it easier to push and maneuver in tight spaces.
Buyers prioritizing ergonomic comfort
The Scotts mower features an ergonomic handle with a cushioned grip. This design reduces hand fatigue during longer mowing sessions. The tool-less assembly simplifies setup before you start. The dual 10-inch tracking wheels provide stable movement across flat terrain, making the manual pushing effort smoother and less strenious for extended periods.
The products compared
American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual
Best for: small, flat lawns
- Power Source
- Manual reel
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Cutting Height
- 1/2 to 2-1/2 in
- Mowing Function
- Grass catcher
- Application
- Lawn
View on Amazon: American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual Affiliate link
This manual reel mower offers a 16-inch cutting width and five blades for a clean scissor-like cut. It weighs 18 pounds and adjusts from 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches. The included grass catcher collects clippings, though results vary. It requires no gas or batteries. This model suits small, level lawns that are mowed frequently. You push it manually, so physical effort is needed.
Pros
- 16-inch cutting width with five blades
- Adjustable cutting height from 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches
- Includes a grass catcher for clipping collection
- Weighs only 18 pounds for easy maneuvering
- Operates quietly without gas, oil, or batteries
Cons
- Requires manual pushing with no motor assistance
- 16-inch width is narrower than the 20-inch Scotts option
- Struggles with tall grass, weeds, or uneven terrain
Good fit if
- You maintain a small, level lawn regularly
- You prefer quiet, zero-emission mowing without cords
- You want a lightweight mower for easy storage
Skip if
- You have a large lawn needing frequent emptying
- You need to cut tall grass or weeds
- You want a wider 20-inch cutting path
Verdict: American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Reel is a lightweight, manual option for small, flat lawns. It fits users who prioritize quiet operation and easy handling over cutting width.
Scotts 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower
Best for: Small, flat lawns needing quiet operation
- Power Source
- Manual
- Cutting Width
- 20 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Cutting Height
- 1-3 in, quick-snap
- Application
- Lawn
- Dimensions
- 28 × 18 × 10 inches
View on Amazon: Scotts 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower Affiliate link
The Scotts 2000-20S is a manual push reel mower with a 20-inch cutting width and five heat-treated alloy steel blades. It features a quick-snap height adjustment from 1 to 3 inches and 10-inch dual tracking wheels. This engine-free model requires no gas or oil. Its lightweight 26.9-pound design and ergonomic handle make it easy to maneuver. It suits users seeking a quiet, zero-emission option for small to medium lawns.
Pros
- 20-inch cutting width covers more ground per pass
- Five-blade ball bearing reel ensures a clean, even cut
- Quick-snap height adjustment ranges from 1 to 3 inches
- Lightweight 26.9-pound build with ergonomic cushioned grip
- Zero emissions and no need for gas or oil
Cons
- Manual push power requires physical effort on thick grass
- Limited cutting height range of only 1 to 3 inches
- No grass catcher included for clippings
Good fit if
- You want a quiet, emission-free mowing experience
- You have a small to medium lawn under 1/4 acre
- You prefer lightweight equipment for easy storage and handling
Skip if
- You need a self-propelled drive for hilly terrain
- You require cutting heights above 3 inches
- You have large properties needing faster mowing speeds
Verdict: Scotts 20-Inch 5-Blade Manual Push Reel Mower is a solid choice for those prioritizing simplicity and eco-friendly operation over power assistance. It fits well for flat, maintained lawns where manual effort is acceptable.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual | Scotts 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower |
|---|---|---|
| Power Source | Manual reel | Manual |
| Cutting Width | 16 in | 20 in |
| Drive Type | Push | Push |
| Cutting Height | 1/2 to 2-1/2 in | 1-3 in, quick-snap |
| Mowing Function | Grass catcher | not stated |
| Application | Lawn | Lawn |
| Dimensions | 21.5 × 22 × 48.8 inches | 28 × 18 × 10 inches |
| Weight | 18 pounds | 26.9 pounds |
| Size | 16" 5 Blade, Grass Catcher | 20-Inch, 5-Blade |
| Color | Red | Green |
| Model | 1604-16 | 2000-20S |
Frequently asked questions
Which mower is lighter to push?
The American Lawn Mower Company model is significantly lighter. It weighs 18 pounds, making it easier to maneuver for users with limited strength. The Scotts mower weighs 26.9 pounds. The extra weight may require more effort to push, especially on uneven ground. Choose the lighter option if handling is your priority.
Do these mowers have height adjustment?
Yes, both models allow you to change the cutting height. The Scotts mower features a quick-snap adjustment system with three settings. This lets you switch heights quickly without tools. The American Lawn Mower Company model also includes height adjustment, though specific settings are not listed. You can tailor the cut to your grass type.
Can I bag the grass clippings?
The American Lawn Mower Company mower includes a grass catcher. This allows you to collect clippings for a cleaner look. The Scotts model is listed as a push reel mower but does not explicitly mention a bagging attachment in its specifications. If you prefer no clippings left behind, the American model is the clear choice.
Which one has a wider cutting deck?
The Scotts mower has the wider cutting deck at 20 inches. The American Lawn Mower Company model cuts a 16-inch swath. A wider deck covers more ground per pass, reducing the time needed to mow larger areas. If you have a bigger lawn, the Scotts width offers better efficiency.
Are these mowers suitable for steep hills?
Manual reel mowers require physical effort to push. The Scotts mower is heavier at 26.9 pounds, which might make pushing uphill more difficult. The American Lawn Mower Company mower weighs only 18 pounds. The lighter weight makes it easier to handle on inclines. Both models rely on your strength, so consider your fitness level.
What colors are available for these models?
The American Lawn Mower Company mower comes in red. The Scotts mower is available in green. Color does not affect performance or durability. It is purely a aesthetic choice. Pick the color that matches your garden equipment or personal preference. Both brands offer durable construction regardless of the finish.