Looking Beyond the Great States 415-16 16-Inch Reel Lawn Mower? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
If you are looking for great states 415 16 16 inch reel lawn mower alternatives, you likely value its quiet, manual operation and lightweight design. The original model offers a 16-inch cutting width and a 20.9-pound weight, making it easy to maneuver in tight spaces. It features five heat-treated alloy steel blades and an adjustable cutting height from 1 to 2.5 inches. These specs suit small lawns where noise and emissions matter.
However, you might want a different blade count, a grass catcher, or a different handle style. The alternatives listed here were chosen because their specs overlap with the original while offering distinct variations. Some models include bagging functions for clipping collection, while others provide seven blades for finer cuts. You will find options in various colors and weights, ranging from 18 to 25 pounds. This guide helps you compare these manual reel mowers based on their published specifications to find the best fit for your yard.
Our top pick: Great States 16-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower.
How each alternative compares
American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual
The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 matches the 16-inch cutting width and manual push drive of the Great States model. It weighs 18 pounds, making it slightly lighter than the 20.9-pound original. This unit adds a grass catcher, which the base Great States model lacks. You get clipping collection without switching power sources. The handle height is taller at 48.8 inches, which may suit taller users better than the original’s T-style grip. Choose this if you want to collect clippings but prefer a lightweight, manual tool for small, flat lawns.
American Lawn Mower 16-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower
This American Lawn Mower 1415-16 shares the 16-inch manual cutting width but weighs 25 pounds, making it heavier than the 20.9-pound Great States mower. It uses a standard push handle rather than a T-style grip. The deck is steel, similar to the original’s alloy construction. You trade some maneuverability for a sturdy build suited for low grass. This model is ideal for users who prioritize a quiet, maintenance-free cut over lightweight handling. It fits small, flat lawns where the extra weight provides stability during the mowing process.
Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower
The Scotts 2607-16S offers a 16-inch cutting width with a 7-blade reel, compared to the Great States 5-blade design. It weighs 23 pounds, slightly more than the original. The handle includes padding for comfort during extended use. You gain finer cutting precision on fine turf types. The unit lacks a bagging system, similar to the base Great States model. This mower is best for homeowners with small to medium lawns who value a lightweight, manual tool with enhanced blade count for a cleaner cut on delicate grass varieties.
American Lawn Mower 16-Inch 7-Blade Reel Mower
This American Lawn Mower 2607-16 features a 16-inch cutting width and a 7-blade reel, exceeding the original’s 5-blade setup. It weighs 21.8 pounds, close to the Great States weight. The handle is a standard push type. You get improved cutting performance for fine grass types. The model includes an SK2 attachment, which the original does not mention. This option suits users who want manual precision and self-maintenance without powered convenience. It is a solid choice for maintaining fine turf with a slightly heavier, robust manual mower.
Earthwise 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower
The Earthwise 1715-16EW provides a 16-inch cutting width with a 7-blade steel reel, offering more blades than the Great States 5-blade model. It weighs 21.8 pounds, slightly heavier than the original. The build is steel, emphasizing durability over weight savings. You gain a robust, manual solution for specific grass types. This mower is ideal for users who prioritize blade count and durability. It fits those who want a sturdy, pollution-free cut without electric power, accepting the slight weight increase for enhanced cutting performance and long-term reliability.
Craftsman 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower with Bag
The Craftsman 1816-16CR matches the 16-inch manual cutting width but adds a grass catcher, which the base Great States model lacks. It weighs 23 pounds, heavier than the 20.9-pound original. The handle is a standard push design. You get clipping collection for a cleaner yard without using fuel or electricity. This unit is practical for users with small, well-maintained lawns. It suits those who value a manual, pollution-free cut and want to collect clippings. The added weight provides stability, making it a reliable choice for precise, bagged mowing.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Great States 16-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower
Best for: Small lawns needing quiet manual cutting
- Power Source
- Manual
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Deck Material
- Alloy steel
- Cutting Height
- 1-2.5 in, adjustable
- Application
- Lawn
View on Amazon: Great States 16-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower Affiliate link
This manual push mower features a 16-inch cutting width and a 5-blade reel. It uses heat-treated alloy steel blades for durability. The adjustable cutting height ranges from 1 to 2.5 inches. Weighing 20.9 pounds, it remains lightweight for easy maneuvering. The T-style handle offers a cushioned grip. This tool suits users seeking a quiet, gas-free option for small lawns.
Pros
- 16-inch cutting width with 5-blade reel
- Adjustable cutting height from 1 to 2.5 inches
- Lightweight 20.9-pound build for easy handling
- Cushioned T-style handle for comfort
- Heat-treated alloy steel blades stay sharp longer
Cons
- Requires physical pushing with no power assist
- No grass catcher included for clippings
- Only 5 blades compared to 7-blade competitors
Good fit if
- You want a quiet, emission-free mowing experience
- You have a small lawn under a quarter acre
- You prefer lightweight tools for easy storage
Skip if
- You need to cut thick or wet grass
- You want a larger 18-inch cutting deck
- You prefer self-propelled or electric power
Verdict: Great States 415-16 16-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower fits small yards where quiet operation matters. It offers solid manual performance for light-duty tasks.
American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual
Best for: small, flat lawns needing clipping collection
- Power Source
- Manual reel
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Cutting Height
- 1/2 to 2-1/2 in
- Mowing Function
- Grass catcher
- Application
- Lawn
View on Amazon: American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual Affiliate link
This manual reel mower features a 16-inch cutting width and a five-blade reel for a scissor-like cut. It includes a grass catcher to collect clippings. The cutting height adjusts from 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches. Weighing 18 pounds, it is a push-powered design that requires no gas or batteries. It suits users with small, level lawns who prefer quiet, engine-free operation.
Pros
- 16-inch cutting width with a five-blade reel
- Includes a grass catcher for clipping collection
- Adjustable cutting height from 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches
- Weighs only 18 pounds for easy maneuvering
- No gas, oil, or batteries required
Cons
- Height adjustment requires manual repositioning of components
- Grass catcher may be impractical for heavy clipping volume
- Struggles with tall grass or uneven terrain
Good fit if
- You have a small, level lawn
- You prefer quiet, manual operation
- You want to collect grass clippings
Skip if
- You have large or uneven terrain
- You need to mow tall or overgrown grass
- You prefer electric or gas power sources
Verdict: American Lawn Mower 1604-16 16-Inch 5-Blade is a lightweight, manual option for small, flat lawns where you want to collect clippings without using fuel or electricity.
American Lawn Mower 16-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower
Best for: Small, flat lawns with low grass
- Power Source
- Manual reel
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Deck Material
- Tempered alloy steel
- Cutting Height
- 0.5-2.5 in
- Mowing Function
- Manual reel
View on Amazon: American Lawn Mower 16-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower Affiliate link
This manual push reel mower features a 16-inch cutting width and a 5-blade heat-treated alloy steel reel. It offers an adjustable cutting height from 0.5 to 2.5 inches. The unit weighs 25 pounds and uses durable 10-inch polymer wheels. It provides a quiet, pollution-free mowing experience for small to medium lawns.
Pros
- 16-inch cutting width for efficient coverage
- 5-blade heat-treated alloy steel reel
- Adjustable cutting height from 0.5 to 2.5 inches
- Lightweight 25-pound design for easy maneuverability
Cons
- Requires manual pushing with no engine assist
- Limited to grass up to 4 inches tall
- No grass catcher included for clippings
Good fit if
- You want a quiet, zero-emission mowing option
- You have a small, flat lawn under 4 inches tall
- You prefer lightweight equipment that is easy to store
Skip if
- You have thick or tall grass over 4 inches
- You need a self-propelled mower for hills
- You want to collect grass clippings automatically
Verdict: American Lawn Mower 16-Inch 5-Blade is a solid choice for maintaining small, flat lawns with low grass. It suits buyers who prioritize a lightweight, quiet, and maintenance-free manual tool over powered convenience.
Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower
Best for: small to medium lawns with fine turf
- Power Source
- Manual reel
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Application
- Lawn
- Dimensions
- 19.3 × 21.8 × 49.5 inches
- Weight
- 23 pounds
View on Amazon: Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower Affiliate link
This Scotts manual reel mower offers a 16-inch cutting width with a seven-blade reel for clean cuts on fine to medium turf. Weighing 23 pounds, it features a padded U-handle for comfort and control. The lightweight design aids maneuverability on small to medium lawns. It is a push-only model, requiring no power source, making it suitable for users seeking simple, reliable maintenance without cords or batteries.
Pros
- Seven-blade reel delivers precise cuts on Bermuda, zoysia, ryegrass, and fescue
- Padded U-handle improves comfort and control during use
- Lightweight 23-pound construction allows for easy maneuverability
- 16-inch cutting width covers moderate lawn areas efficiently
Cons
- Push-only design requires physical effort for operation
- No grass catcher included for clippings collection
- Manual reel lacks a built-in sharpener for blade maintenance
Good fit if
- You have a small to medium lawn with fine to medium turf grasses
- You prefer a lightweight, manual mower for easy storage and handling
- You want a padded handle for improved comfort during mowing
Skip if
- You need a self-propelled mower to reduce physical exertion
- You require a grass catcher to collect clippings immediately
- You have large or thick turf that exceeds reel mower capabilities
Verdict: Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower fits homeowners with small to medium lawns who value a lightweight, manual tool with a padded handle for precise cutting on fine grass types.
American Lawn Mower 16-Inch 7-Blade Reel Mower
Best for: Fine grass with manual maintenance
- Power Source
- Manual push
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Cutting Height
- 1/2-2-1/2 in
- Mowing Function
- Reel cut
- Application
- Lawn
- Dimensions
- 27.2 × 21.8 × 45.4 inches
View on Amazon: American Lawn Mower 16-Inch 7-Blade Reel Mower Affiliate link
This manual push reel mower features a 16-inch cutting width and a 7-blade reel designed for fine-textured grasses. It includes an SK-2 hand sharpener to maintain blade performance. The cutting height adjusts from 1/2 inch to 2-1/2 inches. Weighing 21.8 pounds, it remains lightweight for easy maneuvering. It operates without gas, oil, or electricity, offering a quiet and clean mowing experience for small to medium lawns.
Pros
- 7-blade reel for a clean, professional-quality cut
- Includes SK-2 hand sharpener for maintenance
- Adjustable cutting height from 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches
- Lightweight at 21.8 pounds for easy handling
Cons
- Manual push design requires physical effort
- No grass catcher included for clippings
- Sharpener is handheld, not automatic
Good fit if
- You have fine-textured grass like Bermuda or Zoysia
- You prefer a quiet, emission-free mowing experience
- You want to maintain blade sharpness yourself
Skip if
- You need a grass catcher for clippings
- You have large or thick turf areas
- You prefer powered mowing assistance
Verdict: American Lawn Mower 16-Inch 7-Blade Reel Mower suits homeowners with fine grass who value manual precision and self-maintenance over powered convenience.
Earthwise 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower
Best for: Users prioritizing steel durability and seven-blade cuts
- Power Source
- Manual reel
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Deck Material
- Steel side plate
- Cutting Height
- 0.5-2.5 in
- Mowing Function
- Manual reel
View on Amazon: Earthwise 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower Affiliate link
The Earthwise 1715-16EW is a manual push reel mower with a 16-inch cutting width and seven alloy steel blades. It features a durable steel side plate and adjustable cutting height from 0.5 to 2.5 inches. Weighing 21.8 pounds, it offers a planet-friendly alternative to gas mowers. This model suits users seeking a quiet, zero-emission tool for maintaining bent grass varieties like Bermuda and Zoysia.
Pros
- Seven-blade alloy steel reel stays sharp longer
- Adjustable cutting height from 0.5 to 2.5 inches
- Durable steel side plate design
- Suitable for bent grass types like Bermuda and Zoysia
Cons
- No grass catcher included for clippings
- Heavier than 5-blade competitors at 21.8 pounds
- Lacks a built-in blade sharpener mechanism
Good fit if
- You want a seven-blade reel for cleaner cuts
- You prefer a steel side plate for durability
- You mow small lawns with bent grass varieties
Skip if
- You need a grass catcher for clippings
- You want a lighter mower under 20 pounds
- You require a built-in sharpener for maintenance
Verdict: Earthwise 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower provides a robust, steel-built option for users prioritizing blade count and durability over weight savings. It fits those who want a sturdy, manual solution for specific grass types without the need for electric power.
Craftsman 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower with Bag
Best for: collecting grass clippings with a manual mower
- Power Source
- Manual reel
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Cutting Height
- 1-3 in
- Mowing Function
- Bag
- Application
- Lawn
View on Amazon: Craftsman 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower with Bag Affiliate link
The Craftsman 1816-16CR is a 16-inch push reel mower designed for manual operation. It features a 5-blade steel reel and an adjustable cutting height from 1 to 3 inches. A key differentiator is the included grass catcher, making it the best bagging option in this list. Weighing 23 pounds, it offers a padded grip and 10-inch front wheels for maneuverability. It suits users who want a clean cut with clippings collected.
Pros
- Includes a grass catcher for clippings collection
- 16-inch cutting width with 5 steel blades
- Adjustable cutting height from 1 to 3 inches
- Lightweight 23-pound build with padded grip
Cons
- Limited cutting height range of only 1 to 3 inches
- Does not capture all clippings due to reel mechanics
- Requires frequent mowing to handle grass over 4 inches
Good fit if
- You prefer collecting grass clippings in a bag
- You want a manual mower with a wide 16-inch cut
- You maintain a lawn kept under 4 inches tall
Skip if
- You need to mow grass taller than 4 inches
- You require electric or gas power sources
- You need a cutting height adjustment above 3 inches
Verdict: Craftsman 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower with Bag is a practical choice for those who want clippings collected. It fits users with small, well-maintained lawns who value a manual, pollution-free cut.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Great States 16-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower | American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual | American Lawn Mower 16-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower | Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower | American Lawn Mower 16-Inch 7-Blade Reel Mower | Earthwise 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Mower | Craftsman 16-Inch Manual Reel Mower with Bag |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Power Source | Manual | Manual reel | Manual reel | Manual reel | Manual push | Manual reel | Manual reel |
| Cutting Width | 16 in | 16 in | 16 in | 16 in | 16 in | 16 in | 16 in |
| Drive Type | Push | Push | Push | Push | not stated | Push | Push |
| Deck Material | Alloy steel | not stated | Tempered alloy steel | not stated | not stated | Steel side plate | not stated |
| Cutting Height | 1-2.5 in, adjustable | 1/2 to 2-1/2 in | 0.5-2.5 in | not stated | 1/2-2-1/2 in | 0.5-2.5 in | 1-3 in |
| Mowing Function | not stated | Grass catcher | Manual reel | not stated | Reel cut | Manual reel | Bag |
| Application | Lawn | Lawn | Lawn | Lawn | Lawn | Lawn | Lawn |
| Dimensions | 23.1 × 10.6 × 13.8 inches | 21.5 × 22 × 48.8 inches | 45.9 × 21.9 × 27.8 inches | 19.3 × 21.8 × 49.5 inches | 27.2 × 21.8 × 45.4 inches | 45.9 × 21.9 × 27.8 inches | 46 × 22 × 28 inches |
| Weight | 20.9 pounds | 18 pounds | 25 pounds | 23 pounds | 21.8 pounds | 21.8 pounds | 23 pounds |
| Size | 16-Inch, 5-Blade | 16" 5 Blade, Grass Catcher | 16" 5 blade | 16-Inch, 7-Blade | 16" 7 blade + SK2 | 16", 7-blade | 16-Inch with Grass Catcher |
| Color | White | Red | Gray | Black | Blue | Gray | Red |
| Model | 415-16 | 1604-16 | 1415-16 | 2607-16S | 2607-16 | 1715-16EW | 1816-16CR |
When you need compact office screens instead, you can compare viewsonic va1655 16 inch 1080p portable monitor alternatives.
Frequently asked questions
Which reel mower is the lightest option available?
The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 is the lightest choice at 18 pounds. It features a 16-inch cutting width and includes a grass catcher for collecting clippings. This makes it easier to maneuver than heavier models like the Great States 415-16, which weighs 20.9 pounds. You get a manual, fuel-free cut with minimal physical strain.
How does the Scotts 2607-16S differ from the Great States model?
The Scotts 2607-16S uses a 7-blade reel instead of the 5-blade design found in the Great States 415-16. It also features a padded handle for comfort and weighs 23 pounds. This model is designed for fine turf and offers a slightly wider cutting path. You get more blades for potentially cleaner cuts on delicate grass types.
Are there manual mowers with a grass catcher included?
Yes, several alternatives include a grass catcher. The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 and the Craftsman 1816-16CR both feature built-in collection bags. These models allow you to collect clippings without using a separate bag. They are ideal if you want a tidy lawn without the noise and emissions of powered mowers.
Which model offers the most blades for a manual cut?
The Scotts 2607-16S and the Earthwise 1715-16EW both offer seven blades. This is more than the five blades in the Great States 415-16. The American Lawn Mower 2607-16 also provides seven blades. More blades can help provide a finer cut, which is beneficial for maintaining fine turf or smooth lawn surfaces.
Is there a heavy-duty steel option among the alternatives?
The Earthwise 1715-16EW is described as a robust, steel-built option. It weighs 21.8 pounds and features seven blades. This model prioritizes durability over weight savings. It is suitable for users who want a sturdy manual solution without relying on electric power, offering a different build quality compared to the aluminum-style Great States model.
What is the height difference between the top picks?
The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 is the tallest at 48.8 inches. The Scotts 2607-16S follows closely at 49.5 inches. The Great States 415-16 is much shorter at 13.8 inches. This height difference affects storage and handling. You can store the shorter Great States model in tighter spaces compared to the taller alternatives.