Makita vs CRAFTSMAN String Trimmers: Which Brand Fits You?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When you compare makita vs CRAFTSMAN string trimmer, you see two distinct approaches to cordless yard work. Both tools offer a 13-inch cutting width and run on battery power. The main difference lies in their design and power systems. The Makita uses an 18V brushless motor in a traditional fixed shaft. The CRAFTSMAN uses a 20V system with a telescoping shaft that converts to an edger. You also get different battery capacities and line feed systems with each option.
Key differences
| Aspect | Makita 18V Brushless 13-Inch String Trimmer | CRAFTSMAN V20 13-Inch Cordless String Trimmer |
|---|---|---|
| Voltage | 18V | 20V |
| Motor Type | Brushless | Not listed |
| Shaft Type | Fixed | Telescoping |
| Line Feed | Variable speed trigger | Automatic |
| Battery Included | Tool Only | 2.0 Ah |
| Weight | 9.23 pounds | 6.3 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Makita 18V Brushless 13-Inch String Trimmer if
- You prefer a brushless motor for potentially longer motor life and efficiency.
- You want a traditional fixed-shaft trimmer that feels like a standard weed eater.
- You already own 18V LXT batteries and do not need a new battery included.
Choose CRAFTSMAN V20 13-Inch Cordless String Trimmer if
- You need a tool that converts from a trimmer to an edger for versatility.
- You want automatic line advance so you do not have to bump the head to feed line.
- You prefer a lighter unit that comes with a 2.0 Ah battery and charger in the box.
Verdict: Choose the Makita if you value a brushless motor and a traditional fixed-shaft design. Pick the CRAFTSMAN if you need edging capability and automatic line feed. Both offer a 13-inch cut, but their features serve different yard maintenance styles.
Makita vs Craftsman Trimmer Specs
Voltage and Power
The Makita XRU23Z operates on an 18V LXT battery system, while the CRAFTSMAN CMCST900D1 uses a 20V platform. This difference in voltage suggests distinct power delivery profiles for each tool. The Makita features a brushless motor that delivers up to 6,000 RPM, indicating a focus on high rotational speed for efficient cutting. The CRAFTSMAN does not list a specific RPM figure in its specifications. You should consider whether higher voltage or higher RPM matters more for your specific grass conditions and density.
Motor Type
Motor technology is a key differentiator between these two string trimmers. The Makita explicitly lists a brushless motor in its key specifications. Brushless motors typically offer longer life, more power, and better efficiency compared to brushed alternatives. The CRAFTSMAN product data does not specify the motor type. While some CRAFTSMAN variations include brushless options, this specific kit listing does not confirm it. If motor longevity and efficiency are priorities for you, the Makita provides clear data supporting its advanced drive system.
Cutting Width
Both tools offer an identical 13-inch cutting swath. This measurement defines the width of the path cleared with each pass of the trimmer head. A 13-inch width is standard for handheld string trimmers, balancing maneuverability with coverage area. Since both the Makita and CRAFTSMAN share this exact specification, neither holds an advantage in terms of raw cutting width. Your choice will not be influenced by the size of the cut path, as both will cover the same ground per sweep.
Weight and Portability
Weight significantly impacts user fatigue during extended use. The CRAFTSMAN CMCST900D1 weighs 6.3 pounds, making it notably lighter than the Makita XRU23Z, which weighs 9.23 pounds. This nearly three-pound difference is substantial for overhead or prolonged trimming tasks. The CRAFTSMAN also features a telescoping pole, which may affect balance differently than the Makita’s fixed design. If you prioritize a lighter tool that is easier to maneuver, the CRAFTSMAN has a clear advantage in this category.
Line Feed System
How the trimmer advances its line affects convenience and maintenance. The CRAFTSMAN features an automatic line advance system using .065-inch line, which eliminates the need for bumping the head against the ground. This allows for smoother, continuous operation. The Makita data does not specify an automatic feed system, implying it likely uses a standard bump-feed mechanism. For users who want to avoid manually advancing the line, the CRAFTSMAN’s automatic system offers a distinct practical advantage during regular yard work.
Which String Trimmer Fits Your Yard?
You want to trim and edge easily
The CRAFTSMAN features a telescoping shaft that converts to an edger. This dual function saves space and effort. Its automatic line advance keeps the line moving without bumping. You get a 13-inch cutting swath for efficient trimming. The included 2.0 Ah battery and charger mean you can start working right away.
You prefer precise speed control
The Makita offers a variable speed trigger for controlled cutting. It includes a high/low button to manage power and run time. The brushless motor delivers up to 6,000 RPM for consistent performance. You can adjust the speed to match your task. This tool focuses on manual control rather than automatic features.
You need a lightweight tool
The CRAFTSMAN weighs only 6.3 pounds. This light weight reduces fatigue during long sessions. The Makita is heavier at 9.23 pounds. If you plan to hold the tool for extended periods, the lighter CRAFTSMAN is easier to manage. The lower weight makes it more comfortable for overhead or awkward angles.
The products compared
Makita 18V Brushless 13-Inch String Trimmer
Best for: Makita 18V battery owners needing brushless power
- Voltage
- 18V
- Cutting Swath
- 13 in
- Power Source
- battery
- Motor Type
- brushless
- Cutting Width
- 13-Inch
- Included Battery
- Tool Only
View on Amazon: Makita 18V Brushless 13-Inch String Trimmer Affiliate link
This cordless string trimmer runs on Makita 18V LXT batteries and features a brushless motor delivering up to 6,000 RPM. You get a 13-inch cutting swath along with a two-speed High/Low button and variable speed trigger. It suits you if you already own 18V LXT batteries and need controlled trimming power for routine yard maintenance.
Pros
- Brushless motor delivers up to 6,000 RPM
- 13-inch cutting swath
- High/Low power button with variable speed trigger
- Up to 1 hour of run time with an 18V 4.0Ah battery
Cons
- Battery and charger are sold separately
- Bare tool weighs 9.23 pounds
Good fit if
- You already own compatible Makita 18V LXT batteries and chargers.
- You need variable speed control paired with a 13-inch cutting swath.
- You want a brushless motor capable of reaching 6,000 RPM.
Skip if
- You do not own Makita 18V batteries and require an included power pack.
- You need a lightweight trimmer under 9.23 pounds.
Verdict: Makita 18V LXT Brushless 13-Inch String Trimmer fits property owners already invested in the 18V LXT platform who want dual-speed brushless performance. The tool-only configuration targets operators who have compatible batteries ready to deploy.
CRAFTSMAN V20 13-Inch Cordless String Trimmer
Best for: Small yards needing trimmer and edger versatility
- Voltage
- 20V
- Cutting Swath
- 13 in
- Power Source
- battery
- Shaft Type
- telescoping
- Line Feed System
- automatic
- Battery Capacity
- 2.0 Ah
View on Amazon: CRAFTSMAN V20 13-Inch Cordless String Trimmer Affiliate link
This CRAFTSMAN V20 trimmer features a 13-inch cutting swath and an automatic line feed system. It includes a 2.0 Ah battery and converts to an edger via a telescoping pole. You get two speed settings for runtime or power. It suits small yards needing versatile trimming and edging without bumping the line.
Pros
- Automatic .065-inch line feed eliminates bumping
- Converts from trimmer to edger
- Telescoping pole adjusts for comfort
- Two speed settings balance power and runtime
Cons
- 2.0 Ah battery offers limited runtime
- 13-inch cutting swath is narrow
- Brushed motor lacks brushless efficiency
Good fit if
- You need a trimmer that converts to an edger
- You prefer automatic line advance over bump feeding
- You have a small yard under 1/4 acre
Skip if
- You require extended runtime for large properties
- You want a wider cutting deck for efficiency
- You prefer brushless motor technology
Verdict: CRAFTSMAN V20 13-inch Cordless Trimmer fits users needing a versatile trimmer and edger for small lawns. The automatic line feed and conversion capability make it practical for light, frequent maintenance tasks.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Makita 18V Brushless 13-Inch String Trimmer | CRAFTSMAN V20 13-Inch Cordless String Trimmer |
|---|---|---|
| Voltage | 18V | 20V |
| Cutting Swath | 13 in | 13 in |
| Power Source | battery | battery |
| Motor Type | brushless | not stated |
| Shaft Type | not stated | telescoping |
| Line Feed System | not stated | automatic |
| Battery Capacity | not stated | 2.0 Ah |
| Cutting Width | 13-Inch | not stated |
| Included Battery | Tool Only | not stated |
| Dimensions | 8.07 × 40.3 × 8.39 inches | 44 × 8.75 × 5.25 inches |
| Weight | 9.23 pounds | 6.3 pounds |
| Size | 13 inches | 13 inches |
| Color | Teal | Red |
| Model | XRU23Z | CMCST900D1 |
Frequently asked questions
Is the Makita string trimmer heavier than the CRAFTSMAN model?
Yes. The Makita XRU23Z weighs 9.23 pounds. The CRAFTSMAN CMCST900D1 weighs 6.3 pounds. You will notice a difference in hand fatigue during extended use. The CRAFTSMAN is significantly lighter. This makes it easier to hold for long periods. The Makita is heavier due to its brushless motor design.
Does the Makita trimmer come with a battery included?
No. The Makita 18V Brushless String Trimmer is sold as tool only. You must purchase batteries separately. This fits users who already own Makita 18V LXT batteries. You can use your existing power source. This saves money if you are already in the Makita ecosystem.
Can the CRAFTSMAN trimmer be used as an edger?
Yes. The CRAFTSMAN V20 model converts from a trimmer to an edger. This adds versatility for small yards. You can tackle grass edges without switching tools. The automatic line feed also helps during this conversion. It is practical for light, frequent maintenance tasks around your property.
Which trimmer is better for users with existing Makita batteries?
The Makita XRU23Z is the better choice. It is designed specifically for the 18V LXT battery system. You can use your current batteries without buying new ones. This makes it a lightweight tool with variable speed control. It fits users who already own Makita batteries perfectly.
What is the cutting width for both string trimmers?
Both models have a 13-inch cutting width. The Makita XRU23Z and the CRAFTSMAN CMCST900D1 share this spec. This width is standard for residential cordless trimmers. It provides a balanced approach for most lawns. You get consistent coverage regardless of the brand you choose.
Does the Makita trimmer have a brushless motor?
Yes. The Makita XRU23Z features a brushless motor. This type of motor offers longer life and more power. It also provides variable speed control for different tasks. The CRAFTSMAN model does not list a brushless motor in its specs. The Makita offers more advanced motor technology for this price point.