Makita vs EGO Power+ String Trimmers: Which Brand Fits You?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When you research makita vs ego power string trimmer options, you need to understand their core designs. Both tools offer cordless convenience and brushless efficiency. The Makita XRU23Z is a standalone 18V unit with a 13-inch cut. The EGO STA1600 is a 56V attachment for the Multi-Head system, featuring a wider 16-inch cut. You must decide if you need a dedicated tool or a modular system component.
Key differences
| Aspect | Makita 18V Brushless 13-Inch String Trimmer | EGO Power+ 16-Inch Carbon Fiber Trimmer Attachment |
|---|---|---|
| Voltage | 18V | 56V |
| Cutting Swath | 13 in | 16 in |
| Motor Type | Brushless | not listed |
| Shaft Type | Standard | Carbon fiber |
| Weight | 9.23 pounds | 3.4 pounds |
| Line Feed | Variable speed trigger | POWERLOAD or Rapid Reload |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Makita 18V Brushless 13-Inch String Trimmer if
- You want a complete, standalone trimmer with an 18V battery system.
- You prefer variable speed control via the trigger for precise cutting.
- You need a tool that operates independently without a multi-head base.
Choose EGO Power+ 16-Inch Carbon Fiber Trimmer Attachment if
- You already own an EGO POWER+ Multi-Head power head.
- You need a wider 16-inch cutting swath for faster clearing.
- You want a lightweight carbon fiber shaft that reduces fatigue.
Verdict: The Makita XRU23Z is the better choice if you need a dedicated, ready-to-use 18V trimmer. The EGO STA1600 is ideal if you are already invested in the EGO 56V ecosystem and want a lightweight, wide-cut attachment. Your decision depends on your existing battery platform and whether you need a standalone tool or a modular component.
Makita vs EGO Trimmer Specs
Voltage and Power
The Makita XRU23Z runs on an 18V LXT battery system. This provides solid power for standard residential trimming tasks. It delivers up to 6,000 RPM with its brushless motor. The EGO STA1600 is an attachment for the 56V Multi-Head system. While the attachment itself does not list a voltage, it connects to a 56V power head. Higher voltage typically means more torque for thick weeds. You need to check your existing battery inventory to see which system you already own.
Cutting Width
Cutting width determines how much ground you cover in a single pass. The Makita XRU23Z has a 13-inch cutting swath. This is a standard size for home gardens. The EGO STA1600 offers a wider 16-inch cutting swath. The extra three inches can reduce the time needed for larger lawns. A wider cut also means fewer passes over the same area. If you have a large yard, the EGO width offers a practical advantage. Smaller spaces may not benefit from the extra width.
Motor Type
Both tools utilize brushless motor technology. The Makita XRU23Z features a BL Brushless Motor that reduces maintenance and extends runtime. Brushless motors are more efficient than brushed ones. The EGO STA1600 is an attachment, so it relies on the motor in the compatible power head. The product data confirms the Makita has its own integrated brushless motor. This means the Makita is a complete unit with its own drive system. The EGO motor type depends on the separate power head you choose.
Weight and Build
Weight affects fatigue during long trimming sessions. The Makita XRU23Z tool weighs 9.23 pounds. This is for the trimmer only, without a battery. The EGO STA1600 attachment weighs just 3.4 pounds. However, you must add the weight of the power head and battery. The EGO shaft is made of carbon fiber, which is lightweight and durable. The Makita uses a standard construction. The EGO attachment is significantly lighter on its own, but the full system weight varies.
Line Feed System
How you reload trimmer line impacts your workflow. The Makita XRU23Z uses a variable speed trigger and a high/low button for power management. It does not list a specific automatic line feed feature in the data. The EGO STA1600 features POWERLOAD technology. This allows you to feed line by pushing a button. It also supports Rapid Reload for older power heads. The automatic feed system on the EGO can save time when the line wears down quickly.
Battery and Runtime
Runtime depends on your battery capacity. The Makita XRU23Z offers up to one hour of run time with an 18V LXT 4.0Ah battery. The battery is sold separately. The EGO STA1600 is an attachment, so it uses the battery from the 56V power head. The data does not specify a runtime for the EGO because it varies by the head and battery used. You need a compatible 56V battery for the EGO. The Makita provides specific runtime data for a standard battery size.
Choose the right trimmer for you
Users wanting a standalone 18V tool
The Makita XRU23Z is a complete 18V unit with a 13-inch cutting swath. It features a brushless motor delivering up to 6,000 RPM. You get high and low power settings plus a variable speed trigger. Weighing 9.23 pounds, it offers up to one hour of runtime with a 4.0Ah battery, making it a practical choice for standard residential trimming tasks.
Owners of the EGO multi-head system
The EGO STA1600 is a 16-inch attachment for the EGO Power+ Multi-Head system. It features a lightweight carbon fiber shaft and POWERLOAD line feed technology. This tool is compatible with PH1400 and PH1420 power heads. Its IPX4 rating ensures weather resistance. It includes a five-year tool warranty and a lifetime warranty on the shaft, fitting users who already own the power head.
Those needing a wider 16-inch cut
If you need a wider cutting path, the EGO STA1600 offers a 16-inch swath compared to the Makita's 13-inch width. The carbon fiber shaft reduces weight to just 3.4 pounds. This makes it significantly lighter than the standalone Makita unit. The POWERLOAD system allows quick line feeding, saving time during use. It is designed for users who prioritize cutting width and reduced weight.
Users preferring a dedicated handheld unit
The Makita XRU23Z operates as a standalone 18V string trimmer. It does not require a separate multi-head power unit. The brushless motor provides efficient power with reduced maintenance. You can manage run time with the high and low button. The variable speed trigger gives you control over the cutting speed. This makes it a self-contained solution for those who do not want to invest in a multi-tool system.
The products compared
Makita 18V Brushless 13-Inch String Trimmer
Best for: Makita battery owners needing a lightweight trimmer
- Voltage
- 18V
- Cutting Swath
- 13 in
- Power Source
- battery
- Motor Type
- brushless
- Cutting Width
- 13-Inch
- Included Battery
- Tool Only
View on Amazon: Makita 18V Brushless 13-Inch String Trimmer Affiliate link
This Makita tool uses an 18V LXT battery and a brushless motor to deliver up to 6,000 RPM. It features a 13-inch cutting swath and weighs 9.23 pounds. You get a variable speed trigger and a high/low power button for runtime management. It is sold as a tool only, meaning you need a compatible battery. This setup suits users who already own Makita 18V batteries.
Pros
- BL Brushless Motor delivers up to 6,000 RPM
- Variable speed trigger for controlled cutting speed
- High/Low button for power and run time management
- Includes trimmer line in some variations
Cons
- Sold as a tool only with no included battery
- 13-inch cutting width is narrower than the 16-inch EGO option
- Requires separate purchase of 18V LXT battery
Good fit if
- You already own Makita 18V LXT batteries
- You prefer a lighter 9.23-pound tool
- You want variable speed control for precise trimming
Skip if
- You need a wider 16-inch cutting swath
- You do not own compatible 18V batteries
- You want a complete kit with battery included
Verdict: Makita 13-Inch Brushless String Trimmer fits users who prioritize motor efficiency and weight savings over cutting width. It is a solid choice for those with an existing Makita battery ecosystem.
EGO Power+ 16-Inch Carbon Fiber Trimmer Attachment
Best for: EGO Multi-Head system owners
- Cutting Swath
- 16 in.
- Shaft Type
- carbon fiber
- Line Feed System
- POWERLOAD
- Cutting Width
- 16-Inch
- Dimensions
- 39.5 × 7.36 × 5 inches
- Weight
- 3.4 pounds
View on Amazon: EGO Power+ 16-Inch Carbon Fiber Trimmer Attachment Affiliate link
This is a 16-inch cutting swath string trimmer attachment for the EGO Multi-Head system. It features a lightweight carbon fiber shaft weighing 3.4 pounds. The unit uses POWERLOAD technology for quick line feeding on compatible power heads. It includes a dual-line spiral-twist 0.095-inch trimmer line. The construction is IPX4-rated for weather resistance. It suits users who already own an EGO power head and want a durable, low-maintenance trimming solution.
Pros
- 16-inch cutting swath for efficient trimming
- Lightweight carbon fiber shaft at 3.4 pounds
- POWERLOAD technology for rapid line reloading
- IPX4-rated weather-resistant construction
- Includes professional-grade 0.095-inch dual-line trimmer line
Cons
- Requires a separate EGO power head to function
- POWERLOAD compatibility limited to the PH1420 power head
- Shorter 5-year tool warranty compared to the lifetime warranty on the shaft
Good fit if
- You own an EGO Multi-Head system power head
- You prefer a lightweight carbon fiber shaft for reduced fatigue
- You want a weather-resistant attachment for outdoor use
Skip if
- You do not have an EGO power head to attach it to
- You need a standalone string trimmer with its own battery
- You require a wider cutting swath than 16 inches
Verdict: EGO Power+ 16-Inch Carbon Fiber Trimmer is a practical attachment for existing EGO users who value a lightweight build and quick line reloading. It fits those who already have the compatible power head and want a durable, weather-resistant tool for routine yard work.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Makita 18V Brushless 13-Inch String Trimmer | EGO Power+ 16-Inch Carbon Fiber Trimmer Attachment |
|---|---|---|
| Voltage | 18V | not stated |
| Cutting Swath | 13 in | 16 in. |
| Power Source | battery | not stated |
| Motor Type | brushless | not stated |
| Shaft Type | not stated | carbon fiber |
| Line Feed System | not stated | POWERLOAD |
| Cutting Width | 13-Inch | 16-Inch |
| Included Battery | Tool Only | not stated |
| Dimensions | 8.07 × 40.3 × 8.39 inches | 39.5 × 7.36 × 5 inches |
| Weight | 9.23 pounds | 3.4 pounds |
| Size | 13 inches | String Trimmer Attachment |
| Color | Teal | black |
| Model | XRU23Z | STA1600 |
Frequently asked questions
Is the Makita 13-inch trimmer lighter than the EGO attachment?
Yes, the Makita XRU23Z weighs 9.23 pounds. The EGO STA1600 attachment weighs just 3.4 pounds. However, the EGO unit requires a separate power head. You must add the weight of the compatible EGO battery and motor to the attachment weight for a true comparison.
What cutting width does the Makita brushless model offer?
The Makita XRU23Z provides a 13-inch cutting width. This size is suitable for standard residential trimming tasks. It prioritizes motor efficiency and weight savings. You should consider this if you need a compact tool for tight spaces or light overgrowth.
Does the EGO string trimmer come with a battery included?
The provided data does not specify battery inclusion for the EGO attachment. It is designed as an accessory for existing EGO power heads. You likely need a compatible 56V battery and power head already. Check your current EGO ecosystem compatibility before purchasing.
Which brand fits users who already own their batteries?
Makita is ideal for users with an existing 18V LXT battery ecosystem. The XRU23Z is tool-only, allowing you to use your current batteries. EGO users benefit from the STA1600 if they own the Multi-Head system. Both brands leverage existing battery investments effectively.
How heavy is the EGO carbon fiber trimmer attachment?
The EGO STA1600 weighs 3.4 pounds. This lightweight build reduces fatigue during routine yard work. It features a carbon fiber shaft for durability. The low weight makes it easy to maneuver, provided you have the necessary power head attached.
Can I use the EGO attachment without a power head?
No, the EGO STA1600 is a trimmer attachment. It requires a compatible EGO power head to operate. It is not a standalone unit like the Makita XRU23Z. You must ensure you have the correct power source before using this specific model.