PowerSmart or American Lawn Mower Company? Lawn Mowers Compared in 2026
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
This PowerSmart vs american lawn mower company lawn mower comparison looks at two very different tools. Both brands offer red mowers for residential lawns, but they serve opposite needs. One uses a gas engine for power, while the other relies on manual effort. You need to decide between engine power and quiet, eco-friendly operation. The specs below show how their designs, cutting widths, and drive types differ significantly for your yard.
Key differences
| Aspect | PowerSmart 18-Inch 144cc Gas Push Mower | American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual |
|---|---|---|
| Power Source | Gas, 144cc 4-cycle | Manual |
| Drive Type | Push | Manual |
| Cutting Width | 18 in | 16 in |
| Deck Material | Steel | Not listed |
| Mowing Function | Side discharge | Bagging |
| Weight | 58.4 pounds | 18 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose PowerSmart 18-Inch 144cc Gas Push Mower if
- You have tall, thick, or uneven grass that requires engine power.
- You want a wider 18-inch cutting path for faster coverage.
- You prefer a durable steel deck for heavy-duty use.
Choose American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual if
- You want a quiet, zero-emission mower for small, level lawns.
- You need a lightweight unit that is easy to store and lift.
- You prefer a scissor-like cut with a grass catcher included.
Verdict: The PowerSmart is the practical choice for larger or overgrown yards that demand engine power and side discharge. The American Lawn Mower Company unit suits small, flat lawns where quiet operation and easy storage matter most. Your choice depends entirely on your grass height and yard size.
PowerSmart or American Lawn Mower Specs
Power Source
The PowerSmart 18-Inch mower uses a 144cc 4-cycle gas engine. This provides independent power for thick or tall grass without manual effort. The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 is a manual reel mower. It requires no gas, oil, batteries, or electrical cords. You push it to operate. This makes it engine-free and quieter than powered options. However, it demands physical effort from you. If you want mechanical power, the PowerSmart engine is the clear choice. For zero fuel costs and simplicity, the manual reel wins.
Cutting Width
The PowerSmart mower features an 18-inch cutting deck. This wider swath covers more ground per pass, which is efficient for larger lawns. The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 has a 16-inch cutting width. While narrower, it still covers a decent area for smaller yards. The 2-inch difference is noticeable over time but not drastic. The PowerSmart offers slightly more coverage per stroke. The American Lawn Mower is adequate for maintained, level lawns. If you prefer covering more ground quickly, the PowerSmart width is better. For tight spaces, the narrower reel may be easier to maneuver.
Deck Material
The PowerSmart mower is built with a durable steel deck. Steel decks are generally robust and designed for long-lasting use. They can handle rougher terrain and provide stability for the cutting blade. The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 uses a reel system. The data does not specify the exact metal alloy for the reel blades, but reel mowers typically use hardened steel for the cutting blades. The deck structure is minimal compared to a powered mower. The PowerSmart steel deck offers a more substantial build for heavy-duty mowing. The reel mower focuses on lightweight construction rather than heavy-duty durability.
Cutting Height Range
The PowerSmart mower allows you to adjust the cutting height from 1.5 inches to 3.9 inches across five positions. This range accommodates various grass types and conditions effectively. The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 offers a range from 1/2 inch to 2-1/2 inches. This lower range is ideal for a manicured, scissor-like cut on dry, regularly maintained grass. The PowerSmart goes higher, which is better for taller grass. The American mower goes lower, which is better for fine lawns. Each product excels in its specific height preference.
Mowing Function
The PowerSmart mower is designed for side discharge. It efficiently throws grass clippings to the side, which helps keep you mowing through tall, thick grass without clogging. The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 includes a grass catcher for bagging. It collects a portion of the clippings, providing a cleaner look. However, the catcher may be less practical for large lawns or heavy clipping volume. If you prefer leaving clippings on the lawn or dealing with side discharge, the PowerSmart is better. If you want to collect clippings for a tidy appearance, the American mower is the choice.
Which mower fits your lawn needs
You have a small, level lawn
The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 is a manual reel mower that requires no gas or batteries. Its 16-inch cutting width and five-blade reel provide a clean, scissor-like cut on dry, regularly maintained grass. At just 18 pounds, it is lightweight and easy to store. The included grass catcher collects clippings, keeping your yard tidy without the noise or emissions of a powered engine.
You need to cut thick or tall grass
The PowerSmart EasyCut uses a 144cc 4-cycle gas engine to handle thick or tall grass with ease. Its 18-inch steel deck and side discharge function efficiently clear clippings, preventing clogs during heavy mowing. The engine features an auto choke and primer for reliable starts. This push mower provides the power needed for uneven areas or larger yards where manual effort would be too strenuous.
You want adjustable cutting heights
The PowerSmart mower offers five distinct cutting height positions, ranging from 1.5 to 3.9 inches. This allows you to quickly adjust the blade height for different grass types or seasonal conditions. The American Lawn Mower also offers height adjustments, but they require manual repositioning of wheels and rollers. If you prefer simple, quick changes with a lever, the PowerSmart design is more practical for frequent adjustments.
The products compared
PowerSmart 18-Inch 144cc Gas Push Mower
Best for: small yards needing reliable gas power
- Power Source
- gas, 144cc 4-cycle
- Cutting Width
- 18 in
- Drive Type
- push
- Deck Material
- steel
- Cutting Height
- 1.5-3.9 in, 5 positions
- Mowing Function
- side discharge
View on Amazon: PowerSmart 18-Inch 144cc Gas Push Mower Affiliate link
This PowerSmart EasyCut is an 18-inch push mower with a 144cc 4-cycle engine. It features a steel deck and side discharge for efficient grass management. You can adjust the cutting height across five positions, ranging from 1.5 to 3.9 inches. The unit weighs 58.4 pounds and uses 8-inch rear wheels for maneuverability. It is a practical option for small yards where you prefer gas power over electric systems.
Pros
- 144cc 4-cycle OHV engine with auto choke
- Durable 18-inch steel deck
- 5-position height adjustment from 1.5 to 3.9 inches
- Side discharge design for thick grass
Cons
- Push drive requires physical effort
- No grass catcher or mulching kit included
- Heavy at 58.4 pounds
Good fit if
- You have a small yard under 1/4 acre
- You prefer gas engines for consistent power
- You are comfortable pushing the mower manually
Skip if
- You need a self-propelled drive system
- You want to mulch clippings back into the lawn
- You prefer a lighter electric or battery mower
Verdict: PowerSmart EasyCut 18-Inch Gas Mower is a sturdy option for small yards, but its push-only design and lack of mulching capabilities limit its appeal for larger or more complex lawns.
American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual
Best for: small, flat lawns with regular maintenance
- Power Source
- Manual reel
- Cutting Width
- 16 in
- Drive Type
- Push
- Cutting Height
- 1/2 to 2-1/2 in
- Mowing Function
- Grass catcher
- Application
- Lawn
View on Amazon: American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual Affiliate link
This is a manual reel mower with a 16-inch cutting width and a five-blade reel. It offers a cutting range from 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches. The unit weighs 18 pounds and includes a grass catcher. It requires no gas, oil, or batteries. You push it to mow. It suits small, flat lawns that are regularly maintained.
Pros
- 16-inch cutting width with a five-blade reel
- Adjustable cutting height from 1/2 to 2-1/2 inches
- Includes a grass catcher for clipping collection
- Weighs 18 pounds for easy maneuverability
- Zero emissions with no fuel or electricity needed
Cons
- Manual operation requires physical pushing effort
- Struggles with tall grass, weeds, or uneven terrain
- Grass catcher fills quickly and needs frequent emptying
Good fit if
- You have a small, level lawn under 1,000 square feet
- You prefer quiet, emission-free mowing without cords or gas
- You maintain your grass frequently and keep it short
Skip if
- You have a large lawn requiring a bagging system
- You need to cut tall, thick, or wet grass
- Your yard has significant slopes or uneven ground
Verdict: American Lawn Mower 16" Manual Reel Mower is a lightweight, zero-emission option for small, flat lawns. It fits you if you want a quiet, low-maintenance tool for regularly trimmed grass.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | PowerSmart 18-Inch 144cc Gas Push Mower | American Lawn Mower 16" 5-Blade Manual |
|---|---|---|
| Power Source | gas, 144cc 4-cycle | Manual reel |
| Cutting Width | 18 in | 16 in |
| Drive Type | push | Push |
| Deck Material | steel | not stated |
| Cutting Height | 1.5-3.9 in, 5 positions | 1/2 to 2-1/2 in |
| Mowing Function | side discharge | Grass catcher |
| Application | Yard, Small Yards, Lawn | Lawn |
| Dimensions | 27.2 × 14.3 × 20.1 inches | 21.5 × 22 × 48.8 inches |
| Weight | 58.4 pounds | 18 pounds |
| Size | 18 Inch-144cc-5 Heights | 16" 5 Blade, Grass Catcher |
| Color | red | Red |
| Model | DB8618C | 1604-16 |
Frequently asked questions
Which mower is lighter to push?
The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 is significantly lighter at 18 pounds. The PowerSmart DB8618C weighs 58.4 pounds due to its gas engine. You will find the manual reel mower easier to maneuver on small, flat lawns. The gas model requires more physical effort to push.
Does the PowerSmart mower mulch grass clippings?
No, the PowerSmart 18-Inch model does not mulch. It features a side discharge function to eject clippings. This design suits small yards where you can manage ejected debris. It lacks the mulching capabilities needed for recycling nutrients back into the soil.
Can the American Lawn Mower catch grass?
Yes, the American Lawn Mower 1604-16 includes a grass catcher. It uses a bagging function to collect clippings as you mow. This is useful for keeping small lawns tidy. The manual reel design allows for clean collection without the need for a bagging attachment.
What is the cutting width of each mower?
The PowerSmart mower has an 18-inch cutting deck. The American Lawn Mower offers a 16-inch cutting width. The wider deck on the gas model covers more ground per pass. The narrower manual mower is better suited for tight spaces or very small lawns.
Is the PowerSmart mower suitable for thick grass?
Yes, the PowerSmart DB8618C is designed for reliable gas power. Its 144cc engine handles thick or tall grass without manual effort. The American Lawn Mower is better for regularly trimmed, dry grass. It struggles with overgrown or dense vegetation due to its manual reel operation.
How many height adjustments does the PowerSmart have?
The PowerSmart 18-Inch mower offers five height settings. This allows you to adjust the cut for different lawn conditions. The American Lawn Mower 1604-16 is a manual reel mower with fixed height. You cannot adjust the cutting height on the manual model.
Which mower is better for small yards?
Both mowers fit small yards but serve different needs. The PowerSmart is ideal for small yards needing reliable gas power. The American Lawn Mower suits small, flat lawns with regular maintenance. Choose the gas model for ease of use and the manual one for zero emissions.